Hip-Hop Lunchroom: 5 Categories of Today’s Rappers

Written by The Rap Up. Posted in Chin Check

Published on June 18, 2009 with 71 Comments">71 Comments


Pictured above: Soulja Toy and Chuck Hamlet

Today’s hip-hop landscape looks a lot like the lunchroom at an urban high school. What began as one thing, has grown into another, much bigger, more fractured thing altogether. While the casual observer might look at the rap genre as one thing, the more dedicated listener will note the distinct sub-categories that the music has to offer. Each category, while separate, will contain a bit of overlap for two reasons. First, each artist is influenced by the art of their contemporaries and predecessors. Secondly, what makes the product that each artist creates palatable for large audiences are the cords of similarity within the biographies of the entertainers and their fans. These shared experiences, stories, and viewpoints are the intangible elements that create the culture of hip-hop.

Here are the categories and their most notable figures:

The Cool Kids

wale-inside-looking-out
High on pop appeal and low on lyrical content, these are the artists who have capitalized on style alone. They are pop artists as much as hip-hoppers. This class of rapper is very likely to have invented a dance to go along with one of their songs, worn white sunglasses, made songs that deal with their extravagant lifestyles, and catered to their female fans.
Notable Figures: Drake, Wale, Soulja boy,

The Gangsters/Soldiers

What A Clown

There is a contingent of people who have resigned themselves to illegal means of gain for a variety of reasons. The hope is to gain “Kingpin” status and not have to maintain this high risk lifestyle forever. Although the dream is unrealistic for the vast majority of people (like making it to the NBA), it seems that this groups population keeps growing. Here, you can expect to find stories of drug sales, gun play and unrealistic stories of the interplay between high and low life.
Notable Figures: Jeezy, Wayne, Jadakiss, Gucci Mane

The Kingpins

two-quarters
When you think about this group, envision Frank Lucas. They started as bottom feeders with nothing going for them and have built their respective empires on the combination of underworld and legitimate business dealings. They now rub shoulders unapologetically with high society and they rarely forget their table manners. However, every once in a while, they find occasion to remind us where they came from.
Notable Figures: Rick Ross, 50 Cent, Jay-Z, T.I.

The Outsiders (read: Weird Kids)

This group is made up the people who came from circumstances where they were unable to be themselves. Since parlaying their oddities into success, they have begun to garner quite a following among those with odd interests and tested the limits of what is acceptable.
Notable Figures: Kid Cudi, Eminem, Asher Roth, Charles Hamilton

The Disciples

black-star
The true believers of the rap game are not likely to get the same commercial attention because of the way that people think about rap. The average high school student buying the newest rap album for their house party while their parents are out of town is no mood to be preached at. For this reason, artists in this category have what could be considered a cult following. In general, people who claim with pride that they listen to “underground rap” they have discovered an artist in this category. Once one of these artist gets a taste of fame, it is not unusual to hear them attempt to make a mainstream. It usually doesn’t go as well as they’d like.
Notable Figures: Brother Ali, Mos Def, MF Doom, Talib Kweli, Nas

  • Nahshon

    damn, I stop checking comments for a minute ya’ll get all Mavis Beacon on me. I appreciate the lively debate, although I think some people take it a bit seriously. I used to think that I was entitled to my opinion, but I guess not. Read and disagree, but do it with a smile, please. Anyway, let’s hit the high points:

    1. Esbee (What up, man!) I’m gonna give ‘comback season’ a cycle and see what i come up with.

    2. Dear Everyone, how much space is there on Wale’s knapsack? Until obama’s train idea comes to fruition, I guess you guys are gonna keep ridin’ Wale’s high speed rail. Stan on!

    3. Drake is pop. That’s who he is. No disrespect. I love the man’s hustle, he is changing the way the game is played. But his entire career is based on style/charisma/charm/etc. dude is not a lyricist. <–(That’s a period.)

    4. ATI – You mad! hahaha. Dog, I love this music. I absolutely love it. Division exists because hip hop represents more than one division of subculture. You sir, are a moron, and even you are entitled to your opinion and i listen to it because it represents the ideas of a demographic that is just like you: Morons. Keep in mind that I never said that I don’t like any of these groups. They are not grouped in order of preference in any way. I was simple pointing out who they are according to my survey of their material. When people make dance songs for top 40, they are pop, ok? Hopefully that helps. I will draw a diagram if you need me to.

    5. J to the AAP – great point on topicality. I will concede that because it is true. But to me, he seems to rely on lame attempts at elocution rather than substance. Like the difference between saying the name of something and being familiar with it. Am I making sense there?

    6. Austin – Seems like you put a lot of thought into this, which I appreciate because I did too, so being one of the few who didn’t just knee-jerk didn’t go unnoticed. I discussed this with Andrew yesterday as well because he brought up an argument similar to yours on Wayne with regards to Rick Ross. My opinion is that their entire catalog reflects a presented biography that fits this category. Wayne’s persona is based around being a dope boy, by which he has been able to step up his style game or whatever else. I agree with you on criteria. I left out a lot of my own criteria for placing each person in a certain category for two reasons: 1) so that followers less prone to actually read the full article would find it less daunting and 2) to stimulate this very conversation. I enjoyed your comments on Asher because he loves his life. But he does discuss the difficulties associated with being a white hip-hop-head when your parents love “white music” on the last track of his album.

    7. I never said that there was anything good about being in the disciples group. So maybe try reading the post before assuming I would ever self proclaim “internet head” status.

    8. I respect Rizoh a lot. I owe him a lot in that he inspired me to extend my writing into hip-hop and put me on when I decided to do it. But he ain’t my daddy and he doesn’t have to agree or cosign what I say, so feel free to direct all comments to me. Thanks.

    All in all, the post was to show how a united group of hip-hoppers is a faceted fraternity. But I guess you guys just wanna fight?

  • Nahshon

    damn, I stop checking comments for a minute ya’ll get all Mavis Beacon on me. I appreciate the lively debate, although I think some people take it a bit seriously. I used to think that I was entitled to my opinion, but I guess not. Read and disagree, but do it with a smile, please. Anyway, let’s hit the high points:

    1. Esbee (What up, man!) I’m gonna give ‘comback season’ a cycle and see what i come up with.

    2. Dear Everyone, how much space is there on Wale’s knapsack? Until obama’s train idea comes to fruition, I guess you guys are gonna keep ridin’ Wale’s high speed rail. Stan on!

    3. Drake is pop. That’s who he is. No disrespect. I love the man’s hustle, he is changing the way the game is played. But his entire career is based on style/charisma/charm/etc. dude is not a lyricist. <–(That’s a period.)

    4. ATI – You mad! hahaha. Dog, I love this music. I absolutely love it. Division exists because hip hop represents more than one division of subculture. You sir, are a moron, and even you are entitled to your opinion and i listen to it because it represents the ideas of a demographic that is just like you: Morons. Keep in mind that I never said that I don’t like any of these groups. They are not grouped in order of preference in any way. I was simple pointing out who they are according to my survey of their material. When people make dance songs for top 40, they are pop, ok? Hopefully that helps. I will draw a diagram if you need me to.

    5. J to the AAP – great point on topicality. I will concede that because it is true. But to me, he seems to rely on lame attempts at elocution rather than substance. Like the difference between saying the name of something and being familiar with it. Am I making sense there?

    6. Austin – Seems like you put a lot of thought into this, which I appreciate because I did too, so being one of the few who didn’t just knee-jerk didn’t go unnoticed. I discussed this with Andrew yesterday as well because he brought up an argument similar to yours on Wayne with regards to Rick Ross. My opinion is that their entire catalog reflects a presented biography that fits this category. Wayne’s persona is based around being a dope boy, by which he has been able to step up his style game or whatever else. I agree with you on criteria. I left out a lot of my own criteria for placing each person in a certain category for two reasons: 1) so that followers less prone to actually read the full article would find it less daunting and 2) to stimulate this very conversation. I enjoyed your comments on Asher because he loves his life. But he does discuss the difficulties associated with being a white hip-hop-head when your parents love “white music” on the last track of his album.

    7. I never said that there was anything good about being in the disciples group. So maybe try reading the post before assuming I would ever self proclaim “internet head” status.

    8. I respect Rizoh a lot. I owe him a lot in that he inspired me to extend my writing into hip-hop and put me on when I decided to do it. But he ain’t my daddy and he doesn’t have to agree or cosign what I say, so feel free to direct all comments to me. Thanks.

    All in all, the post was to show how a united group of hip-hoppers is a faceted fraternity. But I guess you guys just wanna fight?

  • Nahshon

    Me and Andrew on G-chat

    11:58 AM me: got the internet going nuts again

    Andrew: i saw

    11:59 AM careful, my friend
    the Wale inclusion is dicey

    me: this i know
    but i think he let down the community that loves him and they don’t realize it yet

    12:00 PM Andrew: he let them down, fine. but souljaboy doesn’t fall under the same category
    I think had you put Wale, Drake and someone else in there you would have been fine

    12:01 PM me: cool kids? “you’re a jerk”?
    who are those guys?
    from LA, who sing the jerk song…

    Andrew: the new boyz?

    12:02 PM me: there we go

    Andrew: new boyz
    dude
    put The Clipse in with Wale and Drake
    that’s a perfect fit

    12:03 PM me: yeah but they don’t stay in hip hops face enough

    Andrew: who cares
    they fit
    your post wasn’t Rap’s 5 Categories with people who are uber relevant

    me: visibility breeds relevance and everyone i included has remained current in one way or another

    Andrew: I think my point still stands
    you didn’t frame it as such

    12:04 PM me: you’re right that they fit
    it was a personal choice to use people who are in the light right now

    Andrew: right
    and I’m not advocating that you shouldn’t try and use people who are relevant
    relevance most often means newsworthy

    12:05 PM me: i really would have rather discussed Lupe and Cassidy…but what have you done for me lately

    Andrew: I guess I’m saying I would have gone fit over relevance in that situation just so it sat right
    but what have you done for me lately?

    me: sitting right with certain folks was never a concern

    12:06 PM Andrew: look, I’m not trying to fight you on this
    I get why you did it

    12:07 PM me: Can I post this convo in the comments section?

  • Nahshon

    Me and Andrew on G-chat

    11:58 AM me: got the internet going nuts again

    Andrew: i saw

    11:59 AM careful, my friend
    the Wale inclusion is dicey

    me: this i know
    but i think he let down the community that loves him and they don’t realize it yet

    12:00 PM Andrew: he let them down, fine. but souljaboy doesn’t fall under the same category
    I think had you put Wale, Drake and someone else in there you would have been fine

    12:01 PM me: cool kids? “you’re a jerk”?
    who are those guys?
    from LA, who sing the jerk song…

    Andrew: the new boyz?

    12:02 PM me: there we go

    Andrew: new boyz
    dude
    put The Clipse in with Wale and Drake
    that’s a perfect fit

    12:03 PM me: yeah but they don’t stay in hip hops face enough

    Andrew: who cares
    they fit
    your post wasn’t Rap’s 5 Categories with people who are uber relevant

    me: visibility breeds relevance and everyone i included has remained current in one way or another

    Andrew: I think my point still stands
    you didn’t frame it as such

    12:04 PM me: you’re right that they fit
    it was a personal choice to use people who are in the light right now

    Andrew: right
    and I’m not advocating that you shouldn’t try and use people who are relevant
    relevance most often means newsworthy

    12:05 PM me: i really would have rather discussed Lupe and Cassidy…but what have you done for me lately

    Andrew: I guess I’m saying I would have gone fit over relevance in that situation just so it sat right
    but what have you done for me lately?

    me: sitting right with certain folks was never a concern

    12:06 PM Andrew: look, I’m not trying to fight you on this
    I get why you did it

    12:07 PM me: Can I post this convo in the comments section?

  • ATI

    I guess it takes a certain level of cluelessness to do something as strange as grouping Wale with SB, and then having the nerve to question somebody else’s intelligence (or better yet, call people stans as a clever retort). Oh wait, that ‘you mad’ comment really was a stroke of genius, I might have to use that one some time. At least you were smart enough to use the word “survery,” having made it clear that you haven’t actually paid enough attention to some of these artist’s material.

    Wale’s pop now ’cause he put out a wack single? If we used that kind of logic, you may as well call Jay low on lyrics on high on pop appeal (but of course Nas throws out fluff with Chris Brown, roffle, and he’s a disciple!)

    I must have missed the dance crazes that Wale and Drake have started, or this imaginary female-heavy fanbase that Wale has. The Mixtape About Nothing and Comeback Season are clearly must-listens for you, because I don’t require any diagrams, just an indication that a little bit of thought was put into these groupings. And I guess there’s no positive connotation associated with being “a true rap believer” – sounds like a crappy version of “real hip-hop” to me.

  • ATI

    I guess it takes a certain level of cluelessness to do something as strange as grouping Wale with SB, and then having the nerve to question somebody else’s intelligence (or better yet, call people stans as a clever retort). Oh wait, that ‘you mad’ comment really was a stroke of genius, I might have to use that one some time. At least you were smart enough to use the word “survery,” having made it clear that you haven’t actually paid enough attention to some of these artist’s material.

    Wale’s pop now ’cause he put out a wack single? If we used that kind of logic, you may as well call Jay low on lyrics on high on pop appeal (but of course Nas throws out fluff with Chris Brown, roffle, and he’s a disciple!)

    I must have missed the dance crazes that Wale and Drake have started, or this imaginary female-heavy fanbase that Wale has. The Mixtape About Nothing and Comeback Season are clearly must-listens for you, because I don’t require any diagrams, just an indication that a little bit of thought was put into these groupings. And I guess there’s no positive connotation associated with being “a true rap believer” – sounds like a crappy version of “real hip-hop” to me.

  • Nahshon

    My last:
    Dear ATI,
    I appreciated your comical, jabbing tone on this one. And you actually made some good points. Makes it a much more enjoyable experience, right? Thanks for that!

    Here’s my response, I apologize for my humanity. Apparently, I’m not immune to misspelling. I bet that makes you feel like a scholar…

    Jay’s lyrics disappoint me lately so take it how you will. Shoot me an email and I’ll forward you the email that I sent to Nas regarding that monkey crap-flinging-contest that he calls a song with Chris Brown.

    Alright Stanley, 75% of the Wale fans that I know from sources other than this comment section are female. Not a bad thing, just something I noticed. And that is not to say that every person has to match every part of the description of their category.

    Just got done re-listening to comeback season and I can see what you’re saying but I think my previous point to J to the AAP stands. I was never impressed by Mixtape about nothing…but I’ll give it another listen if you insist. (As long as he shouts DC, ya’ll eat it up!)

    Also, from a person with my religious background “true believer” is pejorative term. But I can’t expect you to know that so I’ll be more explicit with the sarcasm next time. Thanks for the heads up on that.

  • Nahshon

    My last:
    Dear ATI,
    I appreciated your comical, jabbing tone on this one. And you actually made some good points. Makes it a much more enjoyable experience, right? Thanks for that!

    Here’s my response, I apologize for my humanity. Apparently, I’m not immune to misspelling. I bet that makes you feel like a scholar…

    Jay’s lyrics disappoint me lately so take it how you will. Shoot me an email and I’ll forward you the email that I sent to Nas regarding that monkey crap-flinging-contest that he calls a song with Chris Brown.

    Alright Stanley, 75% of the Wale fans that I know from sources other than this comment section are female. Not a bad thing, just something I noticed. And that is not to say that every person has to match every part of the description of their category.

    Just got done re-listening to comeback season and I can see what you’re saying but I think my previous point to J to the AAP stands. I was never impressed by Mixtape about nothing…but I’ll give it another listen if you insist. (As long as he shouts DC, ya’ll eat it up!)

    Also, from a person with my religious background “true believer” is pejorative term. But I can’t expect you to know that so I’ll be more explicit with the sarcasm next time. Thanks for the heads up on that.

  • shanetron

    how did spencer pratt not make the list ANYWHERE.

    JOKES/LOLZ

    But really though, where did you go to school at? I have never seen such diversity in cliques in one school.

    Where are the foreign exchange kids at?

    Where are the teachers at?

    I mean, you can judge Drake as a cool kid, but he went to high school, TWICE, and probably wasn’t cool in either of them.

  • shanetron

    how did spencer pratt not make the list ANYWHERE.

    JOKES/LOLZ

    But really though, where did you go to school at? I have never seen such diversity in cliques in one school.

    Where are the foreign exchange kids at?

    Where are the teachers at?

    I mean, you can judge Drake as a cool kid, but he went to high school, TWICE, and probably wasn’t cool in either of them.

  • moneda

    I’d love for this convo to delve into what makes Jay a pop artist and what keeps Nas a disciple. I might have to take a day off from work for that.

    Adding Lupe to the mix would’ve been fun too.

  • moneda

    I’d love for this convo to delve into what makes Jay a pop artist and what keeps Nas a disciple. I might have to take a day off from work for that.

    Adding Lupe to the mix would’ve been fun too.

  • ATI

    I hope you’re talking about his recent singles or what not, ’cause Jay’s lyricism on American Gangster was top-notch!

    I would spell out an argument on why I disagree with Drake being low on lyrics (sidebar, he’s an especially capable songwriter), but I could at least see why he’d be grouped where he was (the female audience, the pop appeal). Mainly ’cause dude has his fair share of ill verses, too many to say he made it off style alone.

    *downloads Back to the Feature -_-

  • ATI

    I hope you’re talking about his recent singles or what not, ’cause Jay’s lyricism on American Gangster was top-notch!

    I would spell out an argument on why I disagree with Drake being low on lyrics (sidebar, he’s an especially capable songwriter), but I could at least see why he’d be grouped where he was (the female audience, the pop appeal). Mainly ’cause dude has his fair share of ill verses, too many to say he made it off style alone.

    *downloads Back to the Feature -_-

  • Dom Corleone

    So “unately” = “unfortunately,” “sleep-inducind” = “sleep-inducing” and “fact-chekig” = “fact-checking” of course.

    It’s late, mind is a bit hazy, forgive me.. Ironic I didn’t even edit my own post. FAIL on my part.

  • Pingback: Wale Is Not Happy About His Critics « Hold the Throne

  • http://my.rawkus.com/xn/detail/u_3do8pki9yd06o CathrynMarie

    I don’t think anyone will disagree with that you hit the nail on every other category besides the Cool Kids one – shits on point…

    I personally agree with stating your opinion and being true to one self BUT when writing an editorial like such, facts should be tied in with opinions; if you feel a certain way about an artist, back up why you feel that way so we will possibly have food for thought. Stating outrageous things just because it’s your opinion should be placed on personal blogs and not hip hop blogs.

    Nahshon, the description you give for Cool Kids does not even come close to a category that Wale falls in. I need for you to show me these tracks where he is dancing, as well as tracks catering to women. Wale has no female fan base like SB or Drake. Overall, we just aren’t checking for him like that…*sidenote, I’ve been rockin to Wale for a few yrs now, thanks to MySpace & him being on their homepage but we really don’t check for him*….Hell, I’m trying to see how Drake even fits into that description – again, what dance song does he have?

    “Drake is pop. That’s who he is” – really Nahshon? lol I don’t consider any urban artist Pop unless they make it to the Top Hits stations and have middle aged white men buying their albums (ie: Kanye West, Sean Kingston). There is nothing Pop about Drake. He is not a lyricist, I will agree. But he is not Pop….Wale isn’t Pop either – he’ll never be played on a Top 40 Hits station…..

    Just thought I’d add some CaT to the debate – folks were on a mission LOL….I can honestly careless about most of the people listed – if it ain’t Plies, it ain’t right! “GIVE ME THAT BECKYYYYYYYYYY!” lol – I kid, I joke :)

  • moneda

    Doesn’t anyone besides myself (and perhaps Nahshon, though he hasn’t stated as much) believe an artist’s subject matter contributes to where they fall categorically? Just because someone isn’t a successful (or talented) pop artist doesn’t mean s/he isn’t a pop artist.

  • Simz

    never again CathrynMarie

  • Pingback: Drake - ‘Comeback Season’ and ‘Room for Improvement’ Re-up | The Rap Up

  • Usher Milk Mustache

    Where do you think Usher would fit into this group? He’s very commercial (see: Usher with a milk mustache) so I’d have to say the cool kids. Still a great rapper though.

  • Pingback: Calling All Trappers! Calling All Trappers!! | The Rap Up

  • Anonymous

    Can someone tell me how many categories of hip hop subcultures?and what are they?

  • Dom Corleone

    So “unately” = “unfortunately,” “sleep-inducind” = “sleep-inducing” and “fact-chekig” = “fact-checking” of course.

    It’s late, mind is a bit hazy, forgive me.. Ironic I didn’t even edit my own post. FAIL on my part.