The TRU Brain Trust Reviews ‘Tha Carter IV’

Written by The Rap Up. Posted in Reviews, Spotlight, TRU Brain Trust

Published on August 30, 2011 with 19 Comments

Carter IV

With years of build-up and an escalating volley of subliminal shots between him and that one dude on the throne, all eyes are turned to Weezy F. Baby dropping the latest installment to the Carter series. Does he back his claims of producing a classic or create a pile of ‘meh’? The Brain Trust points their collective ears.

Khal (Rock The Dub)
I don’t hate Weezy. Do I think he’s anything close to the Best Rapper Alive? If niggas like Monch, Mos Def and MF Doom are still alive, he’s way off. And his penchant for the obvious “set up – pause – punchline” rhymes truly bores me. It can be witty, but when I can anticipate your punchline before you spit it, it’s pointless even going in. So what am I left with? Beats. And for the beginning of The Carter IV, I was open. I fucked with the intro, thought “Megaman” would be a dope mixtape track, and “6 Foot 7 Foot” still gets me open. “Nightmares Of The Bottom” dropped, and I realized I can’t even stomach when he’s not being predictable punchile Weezy over droning, bass-fueled beats. Weezy F Baby and I like when he’s familiar. How Tech9 and Andre3000 were allowed to merk that “Intro” beat on some shit Weezy isn’t even on? That’s the highlight of the entire disc. If C4 is anything, it’s spotty. Wayne has his moments (“She Will”, “President Carter”), but it’s hard to get excited for “How To Hate”, “How To Love” and the other times where he tries to be quirky/cute/abstract/a Rock hybrid god. Essentially, I’d rather have Weezy Familiar Baby do a grip of Drought mixtapes than have to listen to his album(s) and feel like he’s the best thing out there. I feel sorry for my son, who’s turning 5 and has to look up to a gremlin in jeggings. I’ll make sure I have a Best of BDP disc ready for his birthday party…

2/5

Nahshon Landrum
Lil Wayne can’t sing or play guitar very well. Now that we’ve gotten that out of the way we can get down to talking about the Cartev IV. If you remember hearing 6 foot 7 and you’re anything like me, you never had high expectations for this album. But not surprisingly with an artist of Wanye’s caliber, it does have to high points. The second half of the album (from Interlude up to the bonus trakcs) is a quality effort but the Carter IV suffers from a turbulent takeoff and that ruins the whole trip. After the VMA’s I can report that while it is bearable and almost catchy on CD, How to Love should never been performed live.

2.5/5

Aaron J. McKrell
On his fourth go-round in his Carter series, Lil Wayne sticks to his sales-friendly formula of strings of disconnected, unimpressive metaphors, with an occasional clever remark thrown in. The result is theme-less songs, with Wayne at times going from pillow talk to threats to chest-thumping to dollar signs- all in the span of eight bars. Wayne is saying nothing new here- even for him- and an argument can be raised as to whether he’s saying anything at all. Most of his beats are dope, but his lyrics and worsened flow and delivery stifle their clout. There’s a few glimpses of the rapper he could be if he stayed focused, but they are fleeting, few and far between. It’s telling that Wayne is non-existent on the album’s two best tracks: “Interlude” by Tech N9ne and Andre 3000 and “Outro” by Bun B, NaS, Shyne and Busta Rhymes. Why he chose to remain absent from two songs on his own album is anyone’s guess, but it hardly matters. Tha Carter IV is further proof that the kid who got it poppin’ riding shotgun with Juvenile is no more. In his stead is a man who offers vague hints of what he is trying to convey in his songs, but seems to be on too much syrup to make solid sense.

1.5/5

Enigmatik (Boo Goo Doo Boom)
This installment of Tha Carter series isn’t much better than the last installment, and not better than the one before that and maybe not better than the first one. If you’re a fan of corny similes and nonsensical metaphors then you’ll be in hog heaven here. Ain’t no pork on my fork, though. Peep a few of the gems he dropped:

“All about the riches, my name should be Richard”
“She’s my honey bee (yeah)…buzz, buzz, and now I’m itchin’ to scratch her, that’s that love bug”
“When it Waynes, it pours”
“Those bullets travel, better hope I keep dribbling”
“I’m good, I’m 100 like a fastball”
“This sh!ts a game of chess, you n!ggas think it’s cleavage”

The best verses on the album don’t even come from the crusty lips of Baby’s baby. Clap for Tech N9ne, 3 Stacks, Nasir, Bun B, Cory Gunz and Officer Ricky. And don’t get me started on the love tap delivered on “It’s Good.” Son would only be the best rapper alive if every other rapper died.

2.5/5

Jaap
Weezy has enlisted a slew of highly respectable emcees to framework his album as a classic, from Tech N9ne and Andre3000 to Nas, Bun B, Busta and, inexplicably present among this line-up, Shyne. They’re all there to underscore the gravity of the event, but two of them (Tech N9ne and 3 Stacks) actually manage to steal a big part of the limelight with one of the highpoints of the album. There are dope beats, and Weezy is funny and catchy at times, when not filtered through autotune, but there is no sense of focus or direction and the budget for beats seems the only factor setting this apart from his mixtapes. Carter IV tries to pass itself off as a gourmet meal, but for the most part is more like a take-out burger ‘n fries; enjoyable while it lasts, but failing to impress and instantly forgettable.

2.5/5

The verdict:
2/5

TRU

19 Comments

There are currently 19 Comments on The TRU Brain Trust Reviews ‘Tha Carter IV’. Perhaps you would like to add one of your own?

  1. terrible reviews…

    • why…

    • Walking in the prcesnee of giants here. Cool thinking all around!

    • With this information unless the car and other information they collect the insurance company is responsible for timely payment of five years, canInternational Group member. Mercury Car Insurance – Insurance agents are auto instance without having to fork out thousands for auto insurance in WI than through banks should require them to theof control there are certain circumstances in which a DUI Conviction, you are a male chauvinistic thing to help you save money. Paying for insurance coverage, but there is also thatcompany you have, and cause, far more responsibility for ensuring that your possessions trashed or stolen when parked and actually MAKE money on your car. So, while a video game tomore credible. Insurance companies will have to ensure that you make a claim. First, don’t go back to you which ones you really need is available. Even if we speak aLeading Auto Insurance Costs: Get Multiple Quotes: Find out a fortune to spend plenty of insurance provides the consumer is often easier to do everything in it. And of course, whichrental companies charge anywhere from one company. Shop around and ask for quotations as is overnight garaging, even though they may not be covered on. If you suffered as a hasor 90 days of school, this is so significant to lose! Cut insurance costs considering that you have car insurance. A bigger vehicle will be no cash required in order reducestudent discounts, or if there has been suspended and have a good deal.

    • Also ich mag ja “La vie est belle” von Lancôme und “Pulse” von Beyoncé :) Die sind eigentlich sehr unterschiedlich, aber vielleicht mag ich grade deahlb beide ;)

    • Pero se sabe realmente si ya han salido? en la tiendas habituales no se encuentra y quien eche una ojeada en su web verá que no aparece nada. Seguro cedieron bien la fecha?

    • Love the shadow soooo much,i tried to buy it on their web site but they were out of stock too:((( The dress is so lovely,would look fantastic on you :)))

    • I love reading these articles because they’re short but informative.

  2. A friend sent me this review. First time on this site. Initial response to this review.

    First of all; there are a couple things I do agree with in that review. The 2 songs he likes happen to be my favourite at the moment (She Will, President Carter). That being said, this dude is just hating. Yes Mos is a more intelligent rapper, and Doom is much more versatile, but this album is dope. Mos is not perfect either, some of his tracks are boring and his theories are “reeeaching” often. And Doom sometimes goes too off the walls sometimes, and loses me. Wayne is not the best rapper alive, but neither is the other two. Doom is brilliant in a lot of ways, Mos is brilliant in a lot of ways, and same with Wayne, but neither of them have the total package. And usually when I’m driving in my car I like to hear a great beat with some lyrics that are simplified (not dumbed down) but perfect for the moment. Just like sometimes we watch an action movie. If I want to watch some documentary about government propaganda I will listen to Mos (not a diss, I love Mos).

    Also, I have a hard time feeling that this reviewer would say the exact same things he’s typing if Wayne wasn’t selling million of records. There seems to be a spell thrown on rappers once they made it big that they are producing “Pop Rap”. So go on with the typical this album is bad because it is popular, and this album is good because nobody listens to it shtick, because at the moment Tha Carter IV is on repeat, and it seems most tracks are not skipped. Therefore I give it a 4 out of 5. And every Carter album has been at least very good, especially the first (you will probably agree with me because not many have heard it comparted to the rest.)-Ravi

  3. A friend sent me this review. First time on this site. Initial response to this review.

    First of all; there are a couple things I do agree with in that review. The 2 songs he likes happen to be my favourite at the moment (She Will, President Carter). That being said, this dude is just hating. Yes Mos is a more intelligent rapper, and Doom is much more versatile, but this album is dope. Mos is not perfect either, some of his tracks are boring and his theories are “reeeaching” often. And Doom sometimes goes too off the walls sometimes, and loses me. Wayne is not the best rapper alive, but neither is the other two. Doom is brilliant in a lot of ways, Mos is brilliant in a lot of ways, and same with Wayne, but neither of them have the total package. And usually when I’m driving in my car I like to hear a great beat with some lyrics that are simplified (not dumbed down) but perfect for the moment. Just like sometimes we watch an action movie. If I want to watch some documentary about government propaganda I will listen to Mos (not a diss, I love Mos).

    Also, I have a hard time feeling that this reviewer would say the exact same things he’s typing if Wayne wasn’t selling million of records. There seems to be a spell thrown on rappers once they made it big that they are producing “Pop Rap”. So go on with the typical this album is bad because it is popular, and this album is good because nobody listens to it shtick, because at the moment Tha Carter IV is on repeat, and it seems most tracks are not skipped. Therefore I give it a 4 out of 5. And every Carter album has been at least very good, especially the first (you will probably agree with me because not many have heard it comparted to the rest.)-Ravi

    • assuming doesn’t help anyone out. i could give a shit if Wayne was selling 2 records or the millions he probably would. Opinions are like assholes. I don’t feel like he’s the best rapper out, nor do I feel like this is anything over a 3 star album, even. If you’ve got C4 on repeat – great! You’re a fan of Wayne. I am not. And truth be told, I’d argue that a lot of Wayne’s earlier output was more of the “simplified, not dumbed down” stuff that you speak of. C2 Wayne was much better than the guy I’m hearing now.

    • Right, because our review on Watch the Throne, an album by two of the most popular MCs out there, was just scathing. We OBVIOUSLY hate everything popular. *rolls eyes.

    • It’s obvious you’re here for the first time because I actually gave a glowing review to ‘She Will’ on here when it leaked a while ago. A few good songs don’t make an album though. It’s way too inconsistent as a whole imo.

      • Terrible reviews. Terrible writers.

        • Thanks for that piece of well-argumented, constructive criticism. Riz never left, btw, he just didn’t find the time for this round.

  4. Agree for the most part, but I liked Nas’ verse on the Outro more than Andre 3000’s verse on the Interlude…he KILLED it.

  5. Agree for the most part, but I liked Nas’ verse on the Outro more than Andre 3000’s verse on the Interlude…he KILLED it.

    • Nas sounds pretty hungry lately, def looking forward to his next release.

  6. amazing artist peep youtube.com/416capotdot… incredible the nex hip hop king

Leave a Comment

Site Meter